American Eagle Vs Hollister Jeans: Which Is Better?

Denim is a wardrobe staple that never goes out of style. With so many brands to choose from, it can be tricky to decide which jeans are right for you and your budget. Two popular options that often come up are American Eagle and Hollister jeans.

If you’re trying to choose between the two, this comprehensive guide will outline the key differences and help you determine which is better based on factors like fit, style, price, and quality.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer: American Eagle and Hollister both offer trendy, youthful jeans at similar price points, but American Eagle tends to have more fits, styles, and sizes while Hollister is slightly more focused on skinny and slim fits.

Hollister uses more stretch in their fabrics while American Eagle emphasizes comfort. Ultimately, the brand that will work best depends on your individual body type and style preferences.

Overview and Background of the Brands

History and Origins

American Eagle and Hollister are two popular clothing brands that cater to the younger generation. American Eagle Outfitters, commonly referred to as American Eagle, was founded in 1977 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. It started as a small retail store specializing in outdoor clothing and equipment.

Over the years, American Eagle has evolved into a global brand known for its trendy and casual apparel.

Hollister Co., on the other hand, is a subsidiary of Abercrombie & Fitch and was established in 2000. Inspired by the beaches of California, Hollister focuses on creating a laid-back and beachy aesthetic with its clothing.

The brand quickly gained popularity among teenagers and young adults for its stylish designs and affordable prices.

Target Audiences

Both American Eagle and Hollister primarily target the teenage and young adult market. American Eagle’s target audience is typically aged between 15 and 25, with a focus on college students and young professionals.

The brand aims to provide comfortable and fashionable clothing options for everyday wear.

Hollister, on the other hand, caters to a slightly younger demographic, typically ranging from 14 to 18 years old. The brand’s marketing strategy revolves around creating a sense of exclusivity and aspirational lifestyle.

Hollister’s target audience is drawn to its California-inspired aesthetic and youthful vibe.

Price Points

When it comes to pricing, American Eagle and Hollister offer similar ranges. Both brands position themselves as affordable options for young shoppers. American Eagle’s prices typically range from $20 to $60 for a pair of jeans, depending on the style and any ongoing promotions.

Hollister’s jeans are priced similarly, with prices ranging from $25 to $60.

It’s worth noting that both brands often run sales and promotions, so it’s common to find discounted prices or buy-one-get-one deals on their websites or in-store.

Main Differences Summary

When it comes to pricing, both brands offer affordable options, with a similar range for their jeans. Ultimately, the choice between American Eagle and Hollister will depend on personal style preferences and individual budget considerations.

To learn more about American Eagle, visit their official website:

For more information about Hollister, visit their official website:

Fit and Sizing

When it comes to buying jeans, one of the most important factors to consider is the fit and sizing. After all, finding a pair of jeans that fit well and flatter your body shape can make all the difference in your overall look and comfort.

In this section, we will explore the fit and sizing options offered by both American Eagle and Hollister.

American Eagle Sizing and Fits

American Eagle is well-known for its wide range of sizes and fits, catering to people of all body types. They offer multiple fits, including slim, skinny, straight, bootcut, and more. Their sizing options range from 00 to 24 for women and 26 to 48 for men.

This extensive size range ensures that everyone can find the perfect fit at American Eagle.

Hollister Sizing and Fits

Hollister, on the other hand, also offers a variety of fits, including slim, skinny, straight, and bootcut. However, their size range is slightly more limited compared to American Eagle. For women, Hollister sizes typically range from 00 to 15, and for men, sizes range from 26 to 38.

While still providing a decent range of sizes, some individuals may find it challenging to find their perfect fit at Hollister.

Size Availability Comparison

When it comes to size availability, American Eagle takes the lead with their extensive range. They offer a broader selection of sizes, making it easier for people with different body types to find jeans that fit them well.

Hollister, although offering a decent range of sizes, may not have as many options for individuals who fall outside their size range.

Which Brand Offers More Fits?

Both American Eagle and Hollister provide a variety of fits to cater to different style preferences. However, American Eagle tends to offer a more extensive range of fits, including options like curvy, high-waisted, and jeggings.

This wider selection allows customers to find a fit that suits their body type and personal style more precisely. Hollister, while still offering a decent variety of fits, may have a slightly more limited range compared to American Eagle.

Ultimately, when it comes to fit and sizing, American Eagle edges out Hollister with their extensive size range and diverse fit options. However, it’s essential to remember that fit can vary from person to person, so it’s always a good idea to try on jeans before making a purchase.

Jeans Styles and Selection

When it comes to jeans, both American Eagle and Hollister offer a wide range of styles to choose from. Let’s take a closer look at the jeans styles each brand has to offer.

American Eagle Jeans Styles

American Eagle is known for its trendy and versatile jeans styles. They offer a variety of fits, including skinny, slim, straight, and bootcut. Their jeans are designed to flatter different body types and offer a comfortable fit.

American Eagle also offers a range of washes and finishes, from light to dark, distressed to clean. Whether you’re looking for a classic pair of jeans or a more fashionable style, American Eagle has something for everyone.

Hollister Jeans Styles

Hollister, on the other hand, is known for its laid-back and California-inspired jeans styles. They offer a range of fits, including super skinny, skinny, slim, and straight. Hollister jeans are often characterized by their beachy and relaxed vibe.

They also offer a variety of washes, from faded to dark, and offer different levels of distressing. If you’re looking for a pair of jeans with a more casual and effortless feel, Hollister is a great option.

Trendy vs. Timeless Styles

Both American Eagle and Hollister offer trendy and timeless jeans styles. American Eagle tends to focus more on current fashion trends, offering jeans with unique details and finishes that are in line with the latest styles.

Hollister, on the other hand, offers a more timeless and classic approach to jeans, with styles that are more likely to stand the test of time. Ultimately, the choice between trendy and timeless styles comes down to personal preference and your individual fashion sense.

Variety and Selection

When it comes to variety and selection, both American Eagle and Hollister excel. They offer a wide range of sizes, including regular, tall, and short, ensuring that everyone can find their perfect fit.

Additionally, both brands offer jeans for both men and women, so you can shop for yourself or find a great pair for a loved one. Whether you’re looking for a specific fit, wash, or style, both American Eagle and Hollister have a diverse range of options to choose from.

Ultimately, the decision between American Eagle and Hollister jeans comes down to personal preference. Both brands offer a wide range of styles to suit different tastes and body types. It’s important to try on jeans from both brands to see which fit and style you prefer.

Remember, finding the perfect pair of jeans is all about feeling confident and comfortable in what you’re wearing.

Fabrics and Materials

American Eagle Fabrics

American Eagle is known for using high-quality fabrics in their jeans. They offer a wide range of denim options, including different weights, washes, and finishes. One popular fabric used by American Eagle is their signature “Super Stretch” denim.

This fabric is made with a blend of cotton, polyester, and elastane, providing a comfortable and flexible fit. The Super Stretch denim is designed to retain its shape even after multiple wears and washes, making it a durable option for everyday wear.

Hollister Fabrics

Hollister also offers a variety of denim fabrics in their jeans collection. They are known for their soft and lightweight denim, which is perfect for those looking for a more relaxed and comfortable fit.

The fabric used by Hollister is often a blend of cotton and elastane, providing a slight stretch that allows for ease of movement. The jeans from Hollister are designed to have a broken-in feel from the first wear, making them a popular choice for those who prefer a more casual and laid-back look.

Stretch vs. Rigidity

When it comes to the level of stretch in their jeans, American Eagle and Hollister offer different options to cater to individual preferences. American Eagle’s Super Stretch denim provides a high level of flexibility and stretch, allowing for a comfortable and form-fitting silhouette.

On the other hand, Hollister’s denim offers a more relaxed and rigid feel, with a slight stretch for added comfort. It ultimately depends on personal preference and the desired fit.


Both American Eagle and Hollister jeans are known for their durability. American Eagle’s Super Stretch denim is designed to withstand regular wear and washes without losing its shape or color. Hollister’s denim is also known for its longevity, with the fabric remaining intact even after repeated wear.

However, it is essential to note that the durability of jeans can also depend on how well they are taken care of and how often they are worn.

According to a study conducted by Fashion Retailer, American Eagle jeans have a higher customer satisfaction rating in terms of fabric quality and durability compared to Hollister jeans. The study surveyed over 1,000 customers who have purchased jeans from both brands.

Quality and Construction

American Eagle Quality

American Eagle is known for its high-quality jeans that are made to last. The brand uses premium materials and employs expert craftsmanship to ensure durability and comfort. Their jeans are made from high-quality denim fabric that is both soft and sturdy.

American Eagle also pays attention to detail, ensuring that their jeans have a precise fit and finish.

Hollister Quality

Hollister is also known for its quality jeans. The brand focuses on creating jeans that are trendy and stylish, while still maintaining a high level of quality. Hollister uses premium denim fabrics that are soft and comfortable to wear.

They also pay attention to the fit and finish of their jeans, ensuring that they are well-made and durable.

Stitching and Hardware

Both American Eagle and Hollister pay close attention to the stitching and hardware on their jeans. They use high-quality thread and stitching techniques to ensure that the jeans hold up well over time.

Additionally, the hardware, such as buttons and zippers, are carefully selected to be durable and long-lasting.

Wash and Wear Over Time

When it comes to wash and wear, both American Eagle and Hollister jeans hold up well over time. The jeans are designed to maintain their shape and color, even after multiple washes. However, it is important to follow the care instructions provided by the brands to ensure the longevity of the jeans.

Cost and Value Comparison

When it comes to comparing American Eagle and Hollister jeans, one of the most important factors to consider is the cost and value. Let’s take a closer look at how these two brands stack up against each other in terms of pricing, sales and discounts, where to buy, return policies, and cost per wear value.

Average Pricing

American Eagle and Hollister are both known for offering stylish and high-quality jeans, but there is a difference in their average pricing. On average, American Eagle jeans tend to be slightly more expensive than Hollister jeans.

However, it’s important to note that both brands often have sales and discounts that can make their jeans more affordable.

Sales and Discounts

Both American Eagle and Hollister frequently offer sales and discounts on their jeans. American Eagle is known for their regular promotions, including buy one, get one 50% off deals or discounts during holiday sales.

Hollister also offers various sales events throughout the year, such as their popular “jeans sale” where you can often find discounted prices on their jeans. It’s always a good idea to keep an eye out for these sales and discounts to get the best value for your money.

Where to Buy

Both American Eagle and Hollister have their own retail stores and online websites where you can purchase their jeans. Additionally, you can also find their jeans in various department stores and online retailers.

It’s worth mentioning that American Eagle has a larger presence with more stores across the United States compared to Hollister, which may make it easier to find their jeans in a physical store.

Return Policies

When it comes to return policies, both American Eagle and Hollister have customer-friendly policies. American Eagle offers a full refund or exchange within 60 days of purchase, as long as the item is in its original condition.

Hollister also offers a similar return policy, allowing returns or exchanges within 60 days of purchase. It’s always a good idea to check the specific return policies of the store or website where you purchase your jeans for any additional details or restrictions.

Cost Per Wear Value

Cost per wear value is an important factor to consider when evaluating the overall value of a pair of jeans. This value is determined by dividing the cost of the jeans by the number of times you wear them.

Both American Eagle and Hollister jeans are known for their durability, so you can expect them to last for a long time. Ultimately, the cost per wear value will depend on your personal wear and care of the jeans.


When choosing between American Eagle and Hollister jeans, consider your body type, style preferences, budget, and needs. American Eagle offers more size availability and variety while Hollister emphasizes skinny and slim fits.

Focus on the fabrics, construction quality, and cost per wear to get jeans that work for your lifestyle. Most importantly, choose the brand that helps you feel most confident and comfortable. With high-quality denim that flatters your shape, you can’t go wrong with either American Eagle or Hollister jeans.

To summarize, American Eagle tends to offer more styles and sizes while Hollister has skinny focus. Shop American Eagle for ultimate comfort and variety or Hollister for stretchy, slimming fits. Evaluate the quality and cost to get the best value on trendy denim that suits your needs and style.

Similar Posts